Quick and affordable online appraisals of Beanie Babies

Communicate directly with a qualified Beanie Babies specialist and get a fair market valuation of your item, typically in 48 hours or less.

Quick and affordable online appraisals of Beanie Babies

Communicate directly with a qualified Beanie Babies specialist and get a fair market valuation of your item, typically in 48 hours or less.

How much are my Beanie Babies worth?

Do you have a box of Beanie Babies collecting dust in your attic? Do you want to know how much they are worth on today's market? Mearto provides quick and affordable online appraisals of Beanie Babies. All you have to do is click on the “Start Appraisal” button above and follow the steps to send us information about and images of your Barbie Babies. One of our qualified and experienced specialists will review and get back to you with a fair market and insurance value, typically within 48 hours.

Have questions about the valuation provided, or would you like some advice about selling your Beanie Babies? We are here to help! Our platform allows you to chat back and forth with a specialist to ensure that all of your questions are answered. 

When were Beanie Babies first introduced and what was the initial reception?

When toy company Ty Inc. first released the Original Nine Beanie Babies in 1993, they were met with a lukewarm response from consumers. At the time, these small plush toys were just one among many products in the stuffed animal market, and they did not immediately capture the attention of a wide audience. Initially, Beanie Babies were primarily sold in local specialty stores and gift shops, and their popularity was limited to a small group of collectors and enthusiasts. It was not until a few years later, in the mid-1990s, that Beanie Babies started to gain traction and experience a surge in demand.

What were the original nine Beanie Babies?

  1. Chocolate the Moose
  2. Patti the Platypus
  3. Spot the Dog
  4. Squealer the Pig
  5. Legs the Frog
  6. Flash the Dolphin
  7. Splash the Whale
  8. Pinchers the Lobster
  9. Brownie the Bear

At what point did the Beanie Babies craze start?

Ty Warner, the creator of Beanie Babies, began retiring certain designs in 1994 as part of a deliberate strategy to create scarcity and increase collector interest. As collectors realized that certain Beanie Babies were being retired and no longer produced, the demand for these specific designs increased, driving up their value in the secondary market. The Beanie Baby craze gained significant momentum in the mid- to late-1990s as news stories and media coverage highlighted the soaring prices and collector enthusiasm surrounding these small plush toys.

The increasing media attention brought Beanie Babies into the mainstream consciousness, and the emergence of online platforms provided a convenient and accessible avenue for collectors to buy, sell and trade Beanie Babies, thereby amplifying the popularity and frenzy surrounding these toys. eBay, in particular, played a pivotal role in the Beanie Baby phenomenon. The online auction and marketplace platform allowed collectors from around the world to connect and engage in transactions. It provided a vast marketplace where rare and retired Beanie Babies could be bought and sold, enabling collectors to expand their collections and pursue coveted designs that were otherwise difficult to find locally.

Additionally, Ty Inc. implemented clever marketing tactics to create a sense of community and engagement among Beanie Babies enthusiasts. They released a Beanie Babies Club, where members received exclusive benefits and access to special offers. Ty Inc. also encouraged collectors to interact with one another through conventions, events and online forums, fostering a sense of camaraderie and shared passion for the toys.

What was the highest price ever paid for a Beanie Baby?

The highest price ever paid for a Beanie Baby was $670,000 for a prototype of "Peanut the Royal Blue Elephant." This particular variation of Peanut is known for its deep blue color instead of the usual light blue. The record-setting sale took place on eBay in January 2000 and captured significant media attention, further fueling the perception of Beanie Babies as valuable collectibles.

What are most Beanie Babies worth today?

The vast majority of Beanie Babies are not worth a substantial amount in the current market. Many common Beanie Babies can be found for sale at relatively low prices, often ranging from a few dollars to around $20. These are typically the mass-produced and widely available designs that were not retired or considered rare.

On the other hand, certain limited-edition, rare or retired Beanie Babies can still hold some value today. These might include Beanie Babies with unique features, manufacturing errors or those associated with special events or promotions. Some rare Beanie Babies can fetch higher prices, ranging from tens to hundreds or even thousands of dollars, depending on factors like scarcity and collector demand.

What are the most valuable and sought after Beanie Babies?

It is very important to remember that the market for Beanie Babies is dynamic, and the value of specific Beanie Babies can fluctuate. However, here are a few Beanie Babies that have been historically considered valuable and sought-after by collectors:

  1. Princess the Bear: This Beanie Baby was released in 1997 as a tribute to Princess Diana. It features a purple body with a white rose embroidered on its chest. Certain rare editions with manufacturing errors or unique characteristics have been known to command high prices. In January 2019, a rare first-edition Princess Beanie Baby with a PVC (polyvinyl chloride) pellet filling and an authenticated signature by Ty Warner sold for $10,000 on eBay.

  2. Peace the Bear: Peace bears are highly coveted by collectors, especially those from the original 1996 release. The iconic tie-dye design and different generations of Peace bears, including ones with rare tag variations or unique coloring, can contribute to their value. In February 2021, a first-generation Peace Beanie Baby with a unique "transitional" tag (featuring a combination of old and new tag generations) sold for $7,500 on eBay.

  3. Claude the Crab: Claude the Crab, introduced in 1997, became popular due to its vibrant colors and distinct design. Certain rare editions, such as those with the wrong fabric or tag errors, can be highly sought after by collectors. In October 2018, a Claude Beanie Baby with an extremely rare manufacturing error—his name tag was printed upside down—sold for $9,999 on eBay.

  4. Valentino the Bear: Released in 1994 as a special edition for Valentine's Day, Valentino bears gained popularity and value. The most sought-after versions are those with a white face, a brown nose, and multiple errors on the tags. In January 2019, a first-edition Valentino Beanie Baby with numerous tag errors, including a "Gasport" misspelling and a mismatched "birthdate" and "style number," sold for $10,000 on eBay.

  5. Curly the Bear: Curly bears, introduced in 1996, are known for their curly fur and distinct appearance. Limited editions, such as those with unique tag errors or variations, have been known to fetch higher prices in the collector's market. In June 2018, a Curly Beanie Baby with a rare "Fareham, Hants" factory location on the tag—indicating limited production—sold for $5,900 on eBay.

  6. Iggy the Iguana and Rainbow the Chameleon: These two Beanie Babies, released in 1997, are often sought after due to their vibrant colors and unique patterns. Variations with rare fabric or tag errors can command higher values. In April 2019, a pair of Iggy and Rainbow Beanie Babies with authenticated errors on their tags, including incorrect fabric information, sold for $5,750 on eBay.


Lindsey Bourret is the Managing Director at Mearto. In addition to overseeing the daily operations of the business, she also enjoys sharing her extensive knowledge of the fine art and antiques market with our customers through our website, blog, e-newsletter and social media accounts.

Examples of online appraisals

Rebecca Bust / Sculpture

Est. $3000 - $7000

Pink Mid-Century Venetian Glass Bottles with Stoppers

Est. $800 - $1,200

Vintage Pink Cameo Ring

Est. $3000 - $7000

Pierre Bonnard Lithograph

Est. $50 - $200

Antique French Clock

Est. $4,500 - $5,500

Oil On Canvas By Maqbool Fida Hussein

Est. $140,000 - $150,000

We evaluate items from 50+ categories.

If it can be sold at auction, Mearto can provide an online appraisal.

From fine art to furniture, antique firearms, jewelry and more, our specialists apply unparalleled knowledge and expertise to provide a fair market valuation and answer any questions you may have about your item.